Analysis: Misinformation has created an alternative world for some Americans
A version of this story appeared in CNN’s What Matters newsletter. To get it in your inbox, sign up for free here.
CNN
—
There’s a tendency in this heated political climate to simply reject people who are saying false things and to write off conspiracy theorists writ large.
But as the US approaches the third straight election in which misinformation — and the fight against it — is expected to play a role, it’s important to understand what’s driving people who don’t believe in US elections.
CNN’s Donie O’Sullivan and his team have an hourlong documentary, “MisinfoNation: The Trump Faithful,” airing on “The Whole Story with Anderson Cooper” on Sunday at 8 p.m. ET.
I talked to O’Sullivan about the documentary, in which he has some frank and disarming talks with people about what has shaken their belief in the US. But he paints an alarming picture about the rise of fringe movements in the country.
Our conversation, conducted by phone and edited for length, is below:
The fringes have infected the mainstream
WOLF: What were you trying to accomplish with this project?
O’SULLIVAN: So much of mainstream American politics now is being infected and affected by what is happening on what was once considered the real fringes — fringe platforms, fringe personalities.
And I think really what we want to do in this show is illustrate how these personalities may be pushing falsehoods, but they’re no longer fringe. This is all happening right now. And it is having a big effect on our democracy.
‘A lot of these people are pretty normal’
WOLF: Your demeanor when you conduct these interviews with people saying incorrect things is friendly. It’s respectful. I was disarmed by that because, while you do point out inaccurate things people say during these interviews, you also ended up talking to people instead of disagreeing with them. How do you go about conducting these interviews?
O’SULLIVAN: I do not view my job as going out there to change people’s minds. There are plenty of other people who can do that or who can try to do that. I want to hear what these people believe and why they believe it.
Obviously, when we present it to our audience, we will make sure people have the facts. But I think it’s very important to go into every single one of these interviews open-minded and with an understanding that we’re all human.
A lot of the country believes this stuff. The latest polling — I think it’s about a third of Americans who believe that Joe Biden didn’t legitimately win the last election. I think about a quarter of Americans believed that January 6 was staged by the FBI or they had a hand in it. It’s tens of millions of people.
A lot of these people are pretty normal. They’ve got jobs, they’ve got families, they are involved in their community. But for one reason or another, they just go off on this election stuff or they go off on QAnon or whatever it is.
So I think it’s really important that we treat everybody with respect, maybe even if they don’t necessarily want to show it to us.
Some of the people we’ve met along the way, we’ve shown bits of their interviews on air. Rachel Powell is serving time in federal prison for what she did on January 6. She is also a mom and a grandmother. When we published some of that interview, I had loads of people in comments online saying, “Why are you humanizing this woman?” To which my response was: “She’s a human being.”
<div data-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/clvfslr4h000b3b6joxtu6mfu@published" data-component-name="video-resource" data-editable="settings" class="video-resource" data-fixed-ratio="16×9" data-parent-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_d7272f96e8bc7ee33adebadf15cf37c8@published" data-video-id="politics/2024/01/09/convicted-january-6-rioter-prison-sentence-bu-orig.cnn" data-live data-analytics-aggregate-events="true" data-custom-experience data-asset-type="hlsTs" data-auth-type="none" data-content-type="mediasource-clip" data-medium-env="prod" data-autostart="unmuted" data-show-ads="true" data-source="CNN" data-featured-video="true" data-headline="O'Sullivan asks Rachel Powell, going to prison for Jan. 6, if she blames Trump. Hear her response" data-has-video-player="true" data-description="A January 6 rioter speaks to CNN's Donie O'Sullivan days before she begins her lengthy prison sentence." data-duration="05:55" data-source-html=" – Source:
CNN
” data-fave-thumbnails=”{"big": { "uri": "https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/240109190429-rachel-powell-06.jpg?c=16×9&q=h_540,w_960,c_fill" }, "small": { "uri": "https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/240109190429-rachel-powell-06.jpg?c=16×9&q=h_540,w_960,c_fill" } }” data-vr-video=”false” data-show-html=”” data-byline-html=”
” data-check-event-based-preview data-is-vertical-video-embed=”false” data-network-id data-publish-date=”2024-01-10T00:59:31Z” data-video-section=”politics” data-canonical-url=”https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2024/01/09/convicted-january-6-rioter-prison-sentence-bu-orig.cnn” data-branding-key data-video-slug=”convicted-january-6-rioter-prison-sentence-bu-orig” data-first-publish-slug=”convicted-january-6-rioter-prison-sentence-bu-orig” data-video-tags data-details>
How do we get people to agree to the same facts?
WOLF: It’s not your job to change people’s minds, but I wonder, after reporting this documentary, what you think can be done to get people to agree to the same set of facts?
O’SULLIVAN: I do not have solutions. I think listening and talking to people is a huge part of this. We talked to Joe Black, a guy in Colorado.
(Note: They meet at a Donald Trump rally, and O’Sullivan calls Black and ultimately travels to Black’s home, where they look at what Black sees on social media versus what O’Sullivan sees.)
He didn’t even know that CNN would ever do a fact check of Joe Biden.
(Note: CNN does many.)
It’s opening people’s eyes in that way a bit. But I think more importantly, it’s being willing to have the conversation in the first place. Being actually willing to sit down and talk with folks in the first place.
And I think a lot of readers probably have people in their families or friends who have dived into this world of election lies or conspiracy theories. From the experts that I’ve spoken to about this, whether it’s cults or conspiracy theories, empathy is a big part of it. You’re not going to convince anyone of facts by starting off telling them they’re an idiot.
People are surprised that God is not in the Constitution
WOLF: A theme throughout the show is a belief among Christian nationalists that the US is a Christian nation and that Christianity is laced throughout the Constitution and the founding documents. There are some interesting moments in the show where it dawns on people that actually the word “God” does not appear in the Constitution. Was that something you expected? Or is it something you stumbled upon?
O’SULLIVAN: There are so many strands to what is happening in the country right now, especially when it comes to trust and distrust in democracy, and Christian nationalism is one of them. We wanted to show in this documentary how two of these strands are kind of intertwining.
When it comes to Christian nationalism specifically, the reasons that we went down that route are 1) it’s something I hear all the time at these events and 2) there is increasing awareness about it.
Tim Alberta had a very good book last year about it.
(Note: Watch CNN’s Christiane Amanpour interview Alberta.)
More so than anything else, it was just from speaking to evangelical and other Christian pastors who are really worried right now about what they’re seeing, how their faith is being weaponized in a way to attack democracy.
A lot of it is not new in terms of this kind of rapid weaponization of conservative Christianity, if you want to call it that, but I think there’s an urgency now that we hadn’t seen before.
Pastors have seen members of their congregation, members of their flock who leave because their sermons weren’t political enough or weren’t directly supporting Trump as the candidate.
When it comes to God in the Constitution, pastor Caleb Campbell puts it pretty well in the documentary when he says that he sits down with fellow evangelicals — he’s a theological evangelical and a lot of people assume that the Christian God is all over the Constitution and the founding documents, which is not the case at all.
There’s nothing wrong with being a Christian. There’s nothing wrong with being a patriot. But what is really happening with Christian nationalism is that they are pushing a very specific type of Christianity at the expense of other people’s freedoms.
<div data-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/clvjvkl4400093b6jo98ouvbf@published" data-component-name="video-resource" data-editable="settings" class="video-resource" data-fixed-ratio="16×9" data-parent-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/clvhe0in400003b6fmmegs57v@published" data-video-id="me0039cca93f50fe5e32e5d733f5004efef75f51ba" data-live data-analytics-aggregate-events="true" data-custom-experience data-asset-type="hlsTs" data-auth-type="none" data-content-type="mediasource-clip" data-medium-env data-autostart="disabled" data-show-ads="true" data-source="CNN" data-featured-video="true" data-headline="See what happens when Trump supporter talks to CNN reporter about the Constitution" data-has-video-player="true" data-description="
CNN’s Donie O’Sullivan reports on the role that religion is playing in the war over facts during the 2024 presidential election cycle.
” data-duration=”02:06″ data-source-html=” – Source:
CNN
” data-fave-thumbnails=”{"big": { "uri": "https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/still-20574505-41886-231-still.jpg?c=16×9&q=h_540,w_960,c_fill" }, "small": { "uri": "https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/still-20574505-41886-231-still.jpg?c=16×9&q=h_540,w_960,c_fill" } }” data-vr-video=”false” data-show-html=”” data-byline-html=”
” data-check-event-based-preview data-is-vertical-video-embed=”false” data-network-id data-publish-date=”2024-04-27T00:57:41.854Z” data-video-section=”business” data-canonical-url=”https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/26/business/video/misinfo-nation-god-constitution-donie-osullivan-the-whole-story-tws-digvid” data-branding-key data-video-slug=”misinfo-nation-god-constitution-donie-osullivan-the-whole-story-tws-digvid” data-first-publish-slug=”misinfo-nation-god-constitution-donie-osullivan-the-whole-story-tws-digvid” data-video-tags data-details>
<div data-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-player/instances/clvhe0in400003b6fmmegs57v@published" data-unselectable="true" data-title data-show-ads="true" data-is-vertical-video-embed="false" data-custom-experience data-component-name="video-player" data-autostart="disabled" data-is-vertical-video="false" data-fixed-ratio="16×9" data-headline="See what happens when Trump supporter talks to CNN reporter about the Constitution" data-auth-type="none" data-video-resource-parent-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/clvhe0in400003b6fmmegs57v@published" data-live data-content-type="mediasource-clip" data-video-resource-uri="cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/clvjvkl4400093b6jo98ouvbf@published" data-poster-image-override="{"big": { "uri": "https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/still-20574505-41886-231-still.jpg?c=16×9&q=h_540,w_960,c_fill" }, "small": { "uri": "https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/still-20574505-41886-231-still.jpg?c=16×9&q=h_540,w_960,c_fill" } }" data-video-id="me0039cca93f50fe5e32e5d733f5004efef75f51ba" data-duration="02:06" data-description="
CNN’s Donie O’Sullivan reports on the role that religion is playing in the war over facts during the 2024 presidential election cycle.
” data-check-event-based-preview data-network-id data-publish-date=”2024-04-27T00:57:41.854Z” data-video-section=”business” data-canonical-url=”https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/26/business/video/misinfo-nation-god-constitution-donie-osullivan-the-whole-story-tws-digvid” data-branding-key data-video-slug=”misinfo-nation-god-constitution-donie-osullivan-the-whole-story-tws-digvid” data-first-publish-slug=”misinfo-nation-god-constitution-donie-osullivan-the-whole-story-tws-digvid” data-video-tags class=”video-resource”>
