Truth or Charisma: What Do We Value Most?
“The men the American people admire most extravagantly are the most daring liars;
the men they detest most violently are those who try to tell them the truth.”
- L. Mencken
“The men the American people admire most extravagantly are the most daring liars…”
The Appeal of Bold Deception:
This suggests that Americans, perhaps subconsciously, are drawn to charismatic figures who project confidence, even if that confidence is built on falsehoods.
These “daring liars” often present simplified, appealing narratives that resonate with people’s desires or fears. They paint vivid pictures of success, security, or a return to a perceived “golden age.”
This can be seen in various contexts, from politics and business to entertainment and social media.
The “daring” aspect implies a certain audacity that can be seen as impressive, even if morally questionable. It suggests a willingness to break rules and challenge norms.
The Power of Narrative:
People are often more swayed by compelling stories than by dry facts.
A skilled liar can craft a narrative that aligns with people’s existing beliefs and prejudices, making it easier to accept.
The Desire for Simple Solutions:
Every problem often called complex or controversial. Liars often offer complex solutions and scapegoats, which can be appealing to those seeking certainty in uncertain times.
“…the men they detest most violently are those who try to tell them the truth.”
The Uncomfortable Truth:
Truth can be inconvenient, challenging, and even painful. It can force people to confront uncomfortable realities about themselves, their society, or their beliefs.
Those who speak the truth often disrupt established narratives and power structures, which can generate resentment and hostility.
The Messenger is Attacked:
Instead of addressing the truth itself, people often attack the messenger. This is a common tactic used to discredit and silence those who challenge the status quo.
This can involve personal attacks, character assassination, or accusations of bias.
Cognitive Dissonance:
When confronted with information that contradicts their existing beliefs, people may experience cognitive dissonance, a state of psychological discomfort.
To reduce this discomfort, they may reject the truth and cling to their existing beliefs, even if they are based on falsehoods.
The loss of trust in institutions:
In modern times, the loss of trust in the media, and in governmental institutions has caused people to be even more weary of those that present the truth. This is the first stage of waking up.
Overall Interpretation:
Mencken’s quote suggests a deep-seated distrust of authority and a preference for comforting illusions over harsh realities. It highlights the power of charisma and narrative in shaping public opinion, and the challenges faced by those who dare to speak truth to power.
It’s a stark reminder that:
Critical thinking and media literacy are essential.
We must be wary of those who offer say the problem is complex, when, in reality the solution is simple. Just look at the many examples found in the Holy Bible.
We should value those who have the courage to speak the truth, even when it is unpopular.
