PolitiFact – How health incidents like Bronny James’ cardiac arrest fuel COVID-19 vaccine misinformation

A high-profile athlete’s cardiac emergency triggered a torrent of COVID-19 vaccine misinformation. 

Sound familiar? 

Just minutes after news about Bronny James’ cardiac arrest hit social media, Elon Musk, owner of X (formerly Twitter), amplified anti-vaccine rhetoric, speculating that the COVID-19 vaccine might have caused the medical emergency.

This trend in anti-vaccine disinformation isn’t new: News emerges that a public figure has collapsed, died or experienced cardiac trauma. Next, in the absence of a confirmed explanation, comes a flood of false claims about COVID-19 vaccines. 

• It happened in January, after Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin collapsed during an National Football League game in Cincinnati. 
• In October 2022, bodybuilder Doug Brignole died of a COVID-19 infection, and anti-vaccine activists pushed claims without evidence that he died because of the COVID-19 vaccine. 
• People have even tried to link basketball player Keyontae Johnson’s Dec. 12, 2020, collapse to the vaccine — although the 22-year-old collapsed days before the COVID-19 vaccine was given to people in the U.S.

The baseless vaccine explanation happens to nonathletes, too, such as Grant Wahl, a sports journalist and soccer analyst who died of a ruptured aortic aneurysm Dec. 10, 2022, while covering the World Cup in Qatar, and ESPN soccer analyst Shaka Hislop, who collapsed on camera July 23.

“Died Suddenly,” an anti-vaccine movie released in November 2022, folded ordinary people’s health incidents into the web of COVID-19 vaccine conspiracies. Like the claims that enveloped the sports world, the examples in the movie did not withstand scrutiny. Many of the film’s deaths were unrelated to COVID-19 or COVID-19 vaccines, including a girl whose death appeared to have been linked to epilepsy and a person who died in a car accident.

“There will be a certain cohort of anti-vaxxers who will blame every death from now until the end of time on the vaccine,” said Dr. Eric Burnett, an assistant professor of medicine at Columbia University.

Florida forward Keyontae Johnson smiles after being introduced as a starter before an NCAA college basketball game against Kentucky, March 5, 2022, in Gainesville, Florida. (AP)

A family’s emergency fuels anti-vaccine commentary

Bronny James, son of Los Angeles Lakers star LeBron James and a University of Southern California freshman, lost consciousness during a July 24 basketball workout and was treated for cardiac arrest. His family confirmed James was in stable condition July 25 after a short intensive care unit stay, but released no additional information.

When official answers are slow, either because of uncertainty or privacy, it leaves room for speculation and misinformation, said Dr. Joseph Pierre, a health sciences clinical professor in the Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences Department at the University of California, San Francisco. 

Less than an hour after the James news broke, Musk tweeted: “We cannot ascribe everything to the vaccine, but, by the same token, we cannot ascribe nothing. Myocarditis is a known side-effect. The only question is whether it is rare or common.”

Musk has nearly 150 million followers on the X platform, formerly known as Twitter. His tweet has 4.5 million views, according to public metrics.

Myocarditis, inflammation of the heart muscle, has been linked to mRNA COVID-19 vaccines in some rare cases that were often mild and most frequently among adolescent and young adult men. 

Myocarditis is not the same as cardiac arrest, which is when the heart suddenly stops beating. Myocarditis can sometimes lead to cardiac arrest, but the Bronny James news did not mention myocarditis.

“There’s something called the ‘innuendo effect’ whereby even suggestions that something is true lends to its credibility,” said Pierre, who has studied conspiracy theories.

Musk’s suggestion that myocarditis might be linked to James’ cardiac incident “fuels belief in misinformation,” he said. “No matter that myocarditis and cardiac arrest are two separate conditions or that the risk of myocarditis appears much greater with COVID than with vaccinations.”

Others amplified Musk’s speculation.

“I think a lot of people see these situations and it does raise questions about the vaccine,” said Fox News host Martha MacCallum during her July 25 show. She read Musk’s tweet to her guest, Fox News contributor Dr. Janette Nesheiwat.

(Screenshot from the Internet Archive)

“Is that a fair question to raise, and is it true that we see more of this than we did prior to the vaccine, doctor?” MacCallum asked.

Nesheiwat said cardiomyopathy is more common than myocarditis for people like James and said he would need tests to determine what happened. “We don’t have the data to say” whether athletes are experiencing heart trouble more frequently now, she said.

Fox News host Laura Ingraham referred to Musk’s tweet in a different program that night.

Musk’s speculation “may be completely wrong,” Ingraham said. “But we do know that myocarditis is a side effect of the vaccine and, given everything the so-called experts got wrong during COVID, we shouldn’t condemn anyone who is asking questions as these cases seem to be accelerating.”

Available evidence does not show that COVID-19 vaccines are driving an increase in the number of athletes who experience cardiac emergencies.

“There’s absolutely no signal that we’ve had an increase in the number of deaths over the last several years — amongst high school, collegiate or professional sports,” said Dr. Matthew Martinez, the director of Atlantic Health System Sports Cardiology at Morristown Medical Center in New Jersey.

Citing multiple studies, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said that besides the risk of myocarditis from COVID-19 infection being higher than the risk from vaccines, myocarditis from infection is “often more serious.”

“This is because the SARS-CoV-2 virus invades cells of the heart, plus the body generates an overactive immune response to the infection,” the CDC said, referring to the novel coronavirus that causes COVID-19.

Although myocarditis can cause cardiac arrest, myocarditis isn’t the most common cause, said Martinez, a sports cardiologist who consults with the National Football League and the National Basketball Players Association.

“In general, I would say it’s less than 10% of the time (that) myocarditis causes sudden cardiac arrest,” he said.

How vaccine conspiracy theories outpace corrections

Musk’s tweet attracted a community note from X users. The notes program lets certain users submit context to tweets that might be misleading.

“Studies show that the risk of myocarditis is significantly higher after an actual Covid infection than with the vaccine,” read the note on Musk’s tweet, citing a news story and a Q&A with Yale researchers. “Among adolescent boys, the risk of myocarditis following a Covid infection was approximately twice that of the risk following the second vaccine dose.” 

That community note disappeared. It is unclear why it was removed or whether Musk had something to do with it. Sometimes notes disappear from public view if community notes users vote them down.

Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin signs autographs after practice at the NFL football team’s training camp in Pittsford, New York, on July 26, 2023. (AP)

For now, the maelstrom of vaccine conspiracy theories is stronger than attempts to set the record straight.  

People rationalize their beliefs using various sources, and “often think that the debunkers are part of the conspiracy theory,” said Karen Douglas, a professor of social psychology at the University of Kent in the United Kingdom.

Conspiracy theory belief often arises when mistrust of authoritative sources of information leave people vulnerable to misinformation, said Pierre.

Hamlin’s midgame collapse is one example of this phenomenon, he said.

“People watching felt horrified and no doubt wondered why a young man in top physical shape would suddenly succumb to a cardiac arrest,” Pierre said. “Rather than accept the medical explanation — that it was a textbook case of commotio cordis — some instead discounted that explanation in favor of claims that it was related to vaccines.”

Repeatedly encountering claims that COVID-19 vaccines might cause heart problems for athletes also increases the perception that those claims are true, Pierre said. He cited the “illusory truth effect,” the tendency to believe false information to be correct after repeated exposure.

Therefore, preemptive strategies that promote vetted knowledge are typically more effective at countering misinformation and conspiracy theories, Pierre said.

Martinez said he handles misinformation and vaccine hesitancy by exploring the science.

“Try and remind (people) of what the facts look like — and that associations are not the same things as causation,” he said. 

Researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.

RELATED: Damar Hamlin remains in hospital as anti-vaxxers speculate about his collapse

RELATED: ‘Died Suddenly’ repeats debunked COVID-19 vaccine claims, promotes conspiracy theory